You do not need to be a technician to judge a workshop. You need to ask questions that only a well-run business can answer comfortably. Here are the ones that matter, grouped by stage.
Before diagnosis
- What does your diagnostic charge include, and is it credited against repair work?
- Will I get a written report with the readings, not just a verdict?
- Who will actually work on the vehicle, and what qualifications do they hold?
- How long will the car be with you for diagnosis?
Before authorising the repair
- What caused the failure, and how do you know?
- Is this quote for a short engine, a long engine or a complete unit?
- Which parts are new, which are remanufactured, and which are reused?
- Are single-use bolts, seals and gaskets included in the price?
- What happens to the price if the strip reveals more damage — will you stop and call me?
On warranty and paperwork
- What exactly does the warranty cover, for how long and how many miles?
- Is commercial or trade use excluded?
- Is an early oil change a condition of cover, and at what interval?
- Who honours the warranty if the supplier and the fitter are different businesses?
- Will I get an itemised invoice and the build sheet for any supplied engine?
Answers that should concern you
A firm price for internal engine work quoted over the phone without inspection. A refusal to put the warranty terms in writing. Vague wording about "reconditioned to a high standard" with no measurement data. And any workshop that cannot tell you what caused the failure but is confident the repair will hold.
Getting comparable quotes
Send every workshop the same information: registration, engine code, mileage, symptom history and any diagnostic report you already hold. Quotes that differ by a thousand pounds usually differ in scope, not value.

Written by
Gareth Mullen
Editor and IMI Master Technician (Level 4 Diagnostics)

Technically reviewed by
Adaeze Fowler CEng MIMechE
Technical reviewer, automotive engineer
This guidance is general. It does not replace inspection by a qualified technician on your vehicle. Read our editorial policy for how articles are researched, reviewed and updated.
